To Be Renamed!

Identifying and Improving Generic or Incorrect Object Names in Museum Databases

Ethnographic Museum at the University of Zurich


8 59 49

Event finish

⎌

EDITED v. 46

3 days ago ~ Daniela

Research

Reconciling the "Gebrauch" (use) column of the data with Wikidata worked well when the values followed the usual pattern. It was more difficult when the "use" didn't make sense without the object title to guide us.

3 days ago ~ rae_knowler

While testing methods, we also asked ChatGPT for classifications using the prompt: "Attached are descriptions from a German ethnographic collection of over 60,000 objects. Assist in generating categorizations by clustering the entries based on its internal contents, and also compare with the categorizations other German/similar ethnographic collections". Unsupervised/Chat Approach

3 days ago ~ Nwade01

Created an text visualization for both the Objekt Name and the Karte Gebrauch columns to see the most common labels from the original database.Karte GebrauchObject Name

3 days ago ~ Nwade01

JOINED

3 days ago ~ tim_rudiger

Most of the time it does work and saves us a lot of time with cleaning and labeling the data.

3 days ago ~ lina

Sometimes auto-clustering can go wrong...

3 days ago ~ lina

Ideas for further exploration

Two possible approaches:

  • Create a new field for subject headings → generic term Investigate whether there are established vocabularies that could be adopted (or adapted). Review how other museums handle subject headings and terminologies.

  • Use the “Object Name” field → specific term (as specific as possible) Review concrete examples from Tim’s comparative cases to determine how specific object designations are applied in practice.

4 days ago ~ Daniela

The program we first tried on local storage was limited in capability. Then we did data cleaning on names, experimenting with OpenRefine (a very cool tool, we thought). A tool was vibe coded to take pictures from various collections online, compare images and their identifiers. Now we are going to work on how to prepare this data for curators, to research the regions and departments of the objects 🏺

4 days ago ~ loleg

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

The VMZ's catalogue database can export the images of a subset of items (the result of a query, like "All items with question marks in their title"). Unfortunately, it can only export the images as a PDF. I wrote a quick script to extract all the images from the PDF and save them with the item id as the file name: https://gist.github.com/bellisk/c0d80fda6d21d14d45a37fffa4f1a333

4 days ago ~ rae_knowler

We experimented with OpenRefine to rename objects (see screnshot). We also experimented with the application Panoptic (by CERES) for image similarity in locally stored pictures (see screenshot).

4 days ago ~ piloublan

We experimented wih OpenRefine to rename objects. We also experimented with the application Panoptic (by CERES) for image similarity searches in locally stored pictures.

4 days ago ~ piloublan

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

break-through: Tim used embedded models and public API's to grab object photos from other collections - allowed to do a visual comparison of all VMZ-objects which contain a "?" in the object name

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

new approach!!: is there a IIIF Manifest for image similarity?

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

... and: Also no keywording/tagging function in the current database, limiting systematic indexing, searching, and terminology management.

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

Main challenge: The revision of generic terms is hampered by the absence of both a controlled vocabulary and a thesaurus

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

another idea: Systematically review objects with temporary “o.Nr.” designations and match them against objects currently recorded as missing, with the aim of re-identifying and assigning proper inventory numbers.

(o.Nr. means: "object without a [proper] object number", e.g. objects with temporary numbers pending identification)

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

Put together a small set of images to test reverse image research - including the "Schnabelgeiss"

4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

Working in OpenRefine on the quotation marks:

  • added new colum in excel
  • replace (>> Find / >> Replace) all kinds of quotation mark with straigh ones: "...."
4 days ago ~ RebekkaSutter

JOINED

4 days ago ~ piloublan

This morning we decided to start working on two lines: